Is Your Faith Untethered? How to Anchor Your Beliefs in Biblical Authority

In today’s culture, it’s easy for even sincere Christians to build their beliefs on cultural stories instead of Scripture. This post explores the concept of “untethered faith”—a faith that drifts from biblical authority without realizing it. Learn how to recognize the warning signs, understand the subtle cultural forces at play, and get equipped to return to Scripture as your final authority.

What Is “Untethered Faith”?

Untethered faith happens when we say the Bible is our authority, but in practice, we let other voices shape our beliefs. That might be culture, politics, personal preferences, or even well-meaning church traditions. Over time, we stop letting God’s Word define truth and start using it to justify what we already think is true.

When we use the Bible to affirm a cultural story instead of using it to evaluate the culture itself, we’ve swapped authority—and that’s dangerous.

This drift often happens gradually. And if we’re not intentional, we may not even realize it’s happening.

Four Ways Faith Becomes Untethered

These are the key patterns that will help you identify when faith starts drifting from Scripture:

1. Selective Reading

We read the Bible like a highlight reel—skipping challenging passages and only focusing on what we already agree with.

2. Simplification

We shrink deep, rich truths into catchy slogans that lose the depth and tension of God’s Word.

3. Cultural Captivity

Whether conservative or progressive, we read our cultural biases into Scripture instead of out of it.

4. Authority Displacement

We say the Bible is our final authority, but in reality, we give more weight to politics, influencers, or personal feelings.

“When Scripture becomes a tool to support our agenda instead of the lens to shape it, our faith is no longer biblical—it’s cultural.”

How to Know If Your Faith Is Becoming Untethered

Here are some practical reflection questions to help you evaluate your heart:

  • Are you more passionate about political or social issues than discipleship and holiness?
  • Do you only follow teachers who confirm what you already believe?
  • Do you start with your position and then look for Bible verses to support it?
  • Do you ignore difficult teachings because they don’t match modern values?
  • Does your Christianity align more with a cultural tribe than historic church teaching?

If you answered “yes” to any of those, you’re not alone—but it’s time to take action.

The High Cost of Untethered Faith

Untethered faith doesn’t just confuse us—it weakens the church and our witness to the world.

  • Instability: Like a ship without a rudder, we get tossed around by every new idea (James 1:6–8).
  • Division: When everyone reads Scripture through a personal lens, Christians talk past each other.
  • Loss of Witness: Outsiders see our contradictions and conclude we’re just projecting our opinions onto the Bible.

“Claiming biblical authority means nothing if we won’t actually submit to what the Bible says.”

What’s the Solution? Re-Tether to Scripture

Here’s how to start bringing your faith back under the authority of God’s Word.

1. Read the Bible as a Unified Story

It’s not just a collection of verses—it’s one story that points to Jesus. Interpret it through that lens.

2. Be Honest About Your Biases

We all bring assumptions to the Bible. Acknowledge them, and let Scripture challenge you.

3. Trust the Teaching Office of the Church

God gave teachers to the church for a reason (Ephesians 4:11–12). Seek out faithful guides—not just popular ones.

4. Use the Creeds as Guardrails

Documents like the Nicene Creed help us stay within the historic, global understanding of the faith.

5. Aim for Transformation, Not Just Information

Biblical interpretation isn’t about winning debates—it’s about becoming more like Christ.

FAQs About Biblical Authority

Q: What does it mean that the Bible is the “final authority”?

It means Scripture has the last word. When the Bible speaks clearly, nothing else can overrule it—not culture, science, or opinion.

Q: Can culture ever shape how we interpret the Bible?

Culture can help us see things we might miss, but it must always submit to Scripture. We test culture against the Word, not the other way around.

Q: What if Christians disagree about what the Bible says?

Disagreement is normal, but it should drive us deeper into study, prayer, and dialogue, not into relativism or division.

Q: How can I learn to interpret the Bible better?

Take time to study the Bible as a whole story. Consider joining courses to build your framework. Click here to learn more.

Reflection: Who’s Really in Charge?

As you pause and process what you’ve read, consider:

  • Where in your life have you been tempted to affirm Scripture with your lips, but follow culture with your heart?
  • Are there topics or teachings in the Bible you’ve avoided because they challenge you?
  • Who are the voices you’re allowing to shape your theology—and do they truly lead you back to Christ?

Untethered faith isn’t always loud—it’s often quiet, subtle, slow.

But the longer we stay detached from God’s Word, the more our faith becomes unrecognizable.

Today is a good day to return.
Open your Bible.
Ask the Holy Spirit for help.
And let the authority of Scripture anchor you in the truth that leads to life.

“If you hold to my teaching, you are really my disciples. Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” —John 8:31–32

After earning his PhD in Theological Studies, James spent more than a decade in higher education serving as a Vice President and Academic Dean over online and residential schools. He continues to work as a higher education consultant in the areas of online programming and enrollment management.

Verum Seminary would be honored to support you as you prepare for the meaningful calling God has placed on your life. Our admissions team is here to answer any questions you may have along the way.